12/09/2024
The History of E-Collars: From “Shock” to Stimulation video by Robin MacFarlane is posted in the first comment.
I encourage you to watch my friend Robin MacFarlane’s insightful 16-minute video, The History of E-Collars: From “Shock” to Stimulation. In this video, Robin expertly traces the evolution of e-collars, from their inception in the 1950s to their modern-day applications.
The sometimes resistance to e-collars often stems from outdated information rooted in their use from over 70 years ago. Many critics have never been properly trained on the modern e-collar and, unfortunately, are unwilling to learn. This closed-minded approach limits their training toolbox and denies them a valuable tool that can benefit many dogs.
When I was a new trainer, I made it a point to attend a wide range of seminars and dog training schools, even those whose methods I initially disagreed with. My goal was to understand different perspectives, extract what was useful, and discard the rest. This open-minded approach allowed me to develop my unique training style, influenced by trainers I greatly respect as well as those whose methods I chose not to adopt.
Robin MacFarlane, along with Bart and Michael Bellon and Michael Ellis, are trainers I hold in high regard. Their teaching, combined with my experience as a Police K9 Officer and Search and Rescue K9 Team Training Director, has shaped me into the trainer I am today. I am immensely grateful for their guidance and expertise.
I first met Robin when she conducted an e-collar seminar in Michigan. She emphasized using the lowest level of stimulation to teach dogs effectively. Robin is an exceptional communicator and educator, both with people and dogs. After that, I attended many more of her seminars and school.
It’s important to understand that modern e-collars are not about delivering a “shock.” Instead, they provide a gentle, low-level stimulation akin to a tap on the shoulder, guiding the dog on what to do. Robin’s expertise is recognized not only through her own business but also in her role as a consultant for Dogtra, a leading e-collar company.
I often explain to clients that the evolution of e-collars is similar to how telephones have progressed. When I grew up on a farm, we had a rotary-dial phone mounted on the wall with a big earpiece. Today, we don't even have bag or flip phones. But instead, we carry smartphones that are worlds apart from those early models. The same level of advancement applies to e-collars.
At Michigan Dog Training, we specialize in e-collar training, but we recognize that it’s not the right tool for every dog or every owner. That said, the vast majority of dogs benefit significantly when e-collars are used correctly. We always ensure that clients understand how they work, and we even encourage owners to experience the sensation themselves. This way, they can feel confident that it is not painful when properly used.
For those who prefer not to use an e-collar or for young puppies, we provide alternative training methods such as treats and praise tailored to the dog and owner. However, for those with an open mind, the e-collar is an invaluable tool for achieving effective communication and lasting results.
Please see her 16 min. video in the comments. It's an excellent presentation as Robin always does.