05/28/2025
What happens when you rabidly follow the adopt don't shop mantra? Let's see.
You are villainizing ethical breeders who are breeding carefully selected dogs that are proven to fit the breed standard, are free of genetic diseases that they can pass onto their puppies, shortening lifespan and destroying quality of life. You are turning your back on breeders that care deeply about each and every puppy they produce. The ones that carefully vet and screen potential buyers and ensure they are suitable owners for their breed and their dogs. You are trashing on breeders who require that if you cannot keep your dog, you return your dog to the breeder or have the breeder help you find another suitable home. You know, the breeder who prides himself or herself on not having puppies enter the shelter system or rescues. You are demonizing buyers who want a puppy with a predictable temperament and personality, buyers who want to know exactly how big their puppy will get, what coat type their puppy will have, and other traits that are critical to people.
Instead, you are glorifying the backyard breeders and puppy mills who are irresponsibly mass producing puppies that will end up dumped in a shelter or rescue. You are saying that these people deserve homes for their irresponsibly bred genetic nightmares deserve homes more than the puppies produced by the first group of breeders.
You are also glorifying the retail rescues that go overseas, purchase puppy mill dogs by the tens of thousands, import them, (often illegally with forged veterinarian paperwork), invent sob stories about meat market and street dogs, and sell these nightmares for thousands of dollars each.
The fact is, that if ethical breeders are not demonized and villainized, they would produce more puppies. As it is, the vast majority of puppies that an ethical breeder produces end up in pet homes, not show, breeding or working homes. If you leave these breeders alone and let them produce sound, well bred, predictable puppies, they would have more puppies for pet homes.
What would this accomplish? Mainly, if people can go to an ethical breeder to get a well bred puppy, they won't be shopping for backyard bred or mill puppies, or retails rescues and their fabricated sob stories. If ethical breeders are free to advertise and educate freely, novice buyers would choose to go to ethical breeders to get their puppies versus someone down the road whose dog had a random litter of puppies. This would do a great deal to close the market to byb and puppy mills. This is the best way for the general public to do away with byb and mills. This would also force retail rescues to stop importing dogs by the millions to fill shelters.
Oh, and "adopt" is not the correct term for acquiring a rescue dog. You give the shelter or rescue money, so you still purchased a dog. I am NOT saying rescue dogs don't deserve homes. But I'm saying that people are villainizing the wrong breeders. Leave the ethical breeders alone, learn from them, forward their messages, be a part of an actual feasible solution.
Adopt OR shop, but do so responsibly.
Send a message to learn more