09/17/2024
A few of our fur baby parents asked us to research Salmon vs Sardines
As requested… which is the better choice? SARDINES!
Summarized:
Sardines are much healthier. Sardines “in water”, NOT oil, rinse in water to remove 80% of salt added. They are more beneficial than salmon for several reasons. Read below:
Benefits of Sardines for Dogs
Canned sardines are rich in Omega-3 fatty acids and other essential vitamins, like Vitamin D and B12, which help promote strong bones, healthy skin and coat, and optimal cognitive functioning. Additionally, the protein in canned sardines helps build muscles and boosts energy levels. Plus, the presence of Selenium helps support a healthy immune system for your pup!
The calcium found in canned sardines is particularly beneficial for senior dogs who may be more prone to joint issues due to aging. Calcium helps strengthen bones, teeth, nails, and joints while also promoting an overall healthier life. The Omega-3 fatty acids found in canned sardines further support joint health by reducing inflammation that can cause pain or stiffness.
Canned sardines are a healthy and delicious “snack” (not meal, 2 up to twice per week is ok) that can be added to your pup’s diet. Not only are they high in protein, they are also rich in essential vitamins and minerals, making them a great treat for dogs of all breeds and sizes.
- [ ] Heavy metals: Sardines are small, reproduce quickly and a shorter lifespan provides less exposure to potential contaminants like heavy metals and toxins that can accumulate in larger fish such as Salmon. Some canned fish such as tuna can contain heavy metals such as arsenic and mercury. Therefore, canned fish should only be consumed occasionally as a treat - a maximum of 1-2 times a week.
- [ ] Health: Sardines contain higher concentrations of vital Omega-3 fatty acids from a natural source, making them a powerful choice for promoting joint health, reducing inflammation, and supporting a shiny coat. The calcium found in canned sardines is particularly beneficial for senior dogs who may be more prone to joint issues due to aging. Calcium from fish bone helps strengthen bones, teeth, nails, and joints while also promoting an overall healthier life. The Omega-3 fatty acids found in canned sardines further support joint health by reducing inflammation that can cause pain or stiffness.
- [ ] Nutrition: Omega-3 fatty acids and other essential vitamins, like Vitamin D and B12, which help promote strong bones, healthy skin and coat, and optimal cognitive functioning. Additionally, the protein in canned sardines helps build muscles and boosts energy levels. Plus, the presence of Selenium helps support a healthy immune system for your pup!
Below see pasted supportive facts from the articles (some could be a little repetitive) and links to the articles referenced below:
Comparing Sardine and Salmon Omega Supplements for Dogs – Ruby Reese
Comparing Sardine and Salmon Omega Supplements for Dogs
Richer in EPA and DHA
Both sardine and salmon are excellent sources of omega-3 fatty acids, but sardines have the edge when it comes to EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) content. EPA and DHA are the two most biologically active forms of omega-3s, known for their anti-inflammatory properties and overall health benefits (Kris-Etherton et al., 2018). Sardine-based supplements tend to contain higher concentrations of these vital fatty acids, making them a powerful choice for promoting joint health, reducing inflammation, and supporting a shiny coat.
Lower Risk of Contaminants
Sardines are relatively low on the food chain, meaning they have less exposure to potential contaminants like heavy metals and toxins that can accumulate in fish. On the other hand, salmon are higher on the food chain, and their larger size can lead to an increased risk of accumulating certain pollutants (Carrington et al., 2020). Opting for a sardine-based omega supplement may thus offer a safer choice, reducing the likelihood of exposing your beloved pet to harmful substances.
More Environmentally Sustainable
Choosing sardine-based omega supplements can also have a positive impact on the environment. Sardines are a small, fast-growing fish with a high reproductive rate, making them a more sustainable option compared to some salmon species, which can be overfished and face population decline (Hilborn et al., 2020). By opting for sardine-based supplements, you can support more responsible fishing practices and contribute to better marine ecosystem preservation.
Irresistible Taste for Dogs
Palatability is an essential factor when introducing supplements into your dog's diet. Many dogs find the taste of sardines more appealing compared to salmon, which can be beneficial when trying to encourage a picky eater to consume their omega-3 supplement. The added convenience of sardine-based omega supplements being more appetising to dogs can make it easier for pet owners to maintain a consistent supplementation routine.
Conclusion
When it comes to choosing between sardine-based and salmon-based omega supplements for your dog, both options offer valuable health benefits. However, sardine-based supplements have a slight advantage in terms of higher EPA and DHA concentrations, lower risk of contaminants, environmental sustainability, and canine palatability. These factors make sardine-based omega supplements a compelling choice to enhance your dog's overall well-being and support their joint, skin, and cardiovascular health. Before introducing any new supplement to your dog's diet, it is a good idea to consult with your veterinarian. They can assess your pet's specific needs and health condition to determine the most appropriate omega-3 supplement for your furry companion.
https://dogchild.co/blogs/learn/can-dogs-have-canned-tuna-canned-salmon-canned-sardines-and-canned-mussels?srsltid=AfmBOoq9cX3bzVPa-AjiN--6aIvywq-_7AVxSqg7CXl5QGPZrMVQ-bYW
The short answer is yes, in moderation. While canned fish can provide many health benefits for your pup, it should not be the primary protein source in their homecooked diet. Canned fish is high in sodium and can contain heavy metals like mercury and lead if not sourced properly, which can lead to mercury poisoning. Feeding in small portions is always best. As with any food that you feed your pup, it’s best to stick to fresh or frozen options whenever possible, and never serve raw fish as it can cause salmonella poisoning.
Affordable
Another benefit is cost. Rising inflation has made buying fresh fish increasingly difficult for many people on tight budgets. Fortunately, canned fish provides a convenient and affordable alternative that still delivers essential nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids from a natural source. It’s also easy to store and cook—just open up the can and enjoy! Plus, with its long shelf life you can stock up without worrying about wasting food due to expiration dates.
Tips for Choosing Canned Fish for Dogs
1. Choose Water-Based Canned Fish: Canned fish are mixed in with either oil or water. Since the oil is high in fat, it is best not to serve this fatty mixture.
2. No Spices / No Sodium: Canned fish can be high in sodium, so it's best to choose a sodium-free fish or wash the fish. Be extra careful of any spices or smoked flavors added to canned fish. While flavored fish is delicious to humans, dogs should never have it. Especially since many contain onions or onion powder which is poisonous to dogs.
3. Rinse the Fish in Water: To rinse the fish of any sodium, it's best to wash the fish before serving it to your pup. Simply run some cold water over it. Studies have shown that washing can reduce the amount of sodium by 80%.
Cautions
4. Bones: While canned fish companies do their best to not have bones, some do have warnings on labels that they may contain bones. As a pet parent, it's best to check any sort of canned fish you’re feeding.
5. Heavy Metals: Canned fish can contain heavy metals such as arsenic and mercury. Therefore, it should only be consumed occasionally as a treat - a maximum of 1-2 times a week.
6. High in Sodium: Canned foods normally have high sodium. It's best to choose no or low sodium fish and wash your fish before serving it to your dog. Washing can reduce the sodium by over 80%.
7. Spices: Always read labels. Never feed spiced or smoked canned fish to your dog. Some canned fish even contain poisonous ingredients like onion or onion powder.
Now Let’s Dive into the Individual Tinned Fishes for Dogs
Can Dogs Eat Canned Sardines
Canned sardines are a healthy and delicious snack that can be added to your pup’s diet. Not only are they high in protein, they are also rich in essential vitamins and minerals, making them a great treat for dogs of all breeds and sizes.
Benefits of Sardines for Dogs
Canned sardines are rich in Omega-3 fatty acids and other essential vitamins, like Vitamin D and B12, which help promote strong bones, healthy skin and coat, and optimal cognitive functioning. Additionally, the protein in canned sardines helps build muscles and boosts energy levels. Plus, the presence of Selenium helps support a healthy immune system for your pup!
The calcium found in canned sardines is particularly beneficial for senior dogs who may be more prone to joint issues due to aging. Calcium helps strengthen bones, teeth, nails, and joints while also promoting an overall healthier life. The Omega-3 fatty acids found in canned sardines further support joint health by reducing inflammation that can cause pain or stiffness.
Best Dog Sardines for Dogs
Pick sardines packed in water with no spices. Rinse your dog sardines before serving to reduce the sodium content. Can be served fresh from the tin or frozen for a fun enrichment activity or even dehydrated as a treat.
Recipes with Canned Sardines
If you’re looking for a delicious vitamin packed homemade treat - check out our Blueberry Sardine Vitamin Booster recipe for dogs. Our blueberry sardine-based treat is not only easy and quick to make, but it's packed with healthy, nutritious ingredients like omega 3s that will make your pup jump for joy!
BLUEBERRY SARDINE VITAMIN BOOSTER
Category: Frozen Dog Treats
Servings: 12 treats
Prep Time: 0 minutes
Cook Time: 5 minutes
Try this simple and healthy blueberry sardine frozen treat for dogs! Not only is it easy to make, but it's also packed with nutrients and deliciousness. These frozen homemade dog treats are the perfect balance of sweet flavors and healthy benefits. Dogs love these delicious bites, and you'll be relieved knowing that they're getting an extra boost of omega 3s from the sardines as well as the antioxidant-rich benefits of blueberries that helps keep their coat looking shiny. For both owners and dogs alike, this frozen dog treat will ensure everyone enjoys a special snack time!
Author:
Dog Child
INGREDIENTS
* 1 Cup Frozen Blueberries
* 1 Can Sardines
* 1 Cup Chicken Broth
DIRECTIONS
1. Add all ingredients to a blender.
2. Blend until smooth.
3. Pour mixture into a mold.
4. Freeze for 2-3 hours and enjoy!
East Coast Cotons
(508)878-9568 cell
A “Code of Ethics Breeder”
Club Health Advisor and
Board of Directors Member
with the American Coton Club
Location: Rehoboth, MA
Website: www.eastcoastcotons.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/EastCoastCotons?mibextid=LQQJ4d
Preserving the Health & Well-being of the Coton de Tuléar