08/11/2025
"On Tuesday, I went to the USEF/USHJA Town Hall Meeting during Pony Finals at the Kentucky Horse Park, which occurred while USEF Pony Finals was actively showing. While all the top brass were there and claimed to be ready to listen, the event was poorly marketed and even more sparsely attended.
And maybe that’s good, because it showed exactly why change feels impossible in this sport.
I sat there and listened to the governing body blame the stewards for not upholding the rules. I heard them blame trainers. I sat there as punishment was discussed. I sat there while they failed to explain our sport to new members. I heard them discount lifelong horsepeople. I heard them contradict themselves. I heard our longtime leaders profess the need for a culture change.
I wondered if they were part of the same sport I love with my whole heart. The sport where most people are good, where they welcome others in, lift them on their way up, and, maybe more importantly, on their way back up. It’s the sport where horses should come first every single day, and where trainers, judges, stewards, and grooms work so hard they forget to eat, skip the restroom, and think of nothing but their responsibilities. It’s the sport fueled by a dream that demands micromanaging every detail of a horse’s care and performance—a lifelong obsession with creating our best selves and training horses to perform magic.
What I didn’t hear at the Town Hall was anyone truly taking responsibility for our future. Sure, they wanted to pass more rules. But more rules are not a culture change. Since I joined the federation, more and more governing rules each year has been the constant. And more championships. More horse shows. More classes. More pressure. More importance placed on every competition.
The continual “more more more” burdens the people actually doing the work inour sport. It’s nothing new, and certainly not a new direction.
I couldn’t help but sit there thinking of the quote often attributed to Einstein, “Any intelligent fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius, and a lot of courage, to move in the opposite direction.”
I listen to these meetings, feeling that they are so at odds with my lived experience at the horse shows. Over thousands of interviews, friendships, and horse shows, most people truly want to and seek out following every single rule always. Posts come up almost every day on The Plaid Horse Adult Amateur Lounge asking for clarification of the rules. Instead of being a standard for our sport, rules are being consistently contradicted or ignored for their own national championships with no repercussions. I frequently ask about rules to those working in the governing body, and often find myself feeling belittled and told that I don’t understand.
Why is our rulebook so hard to follow?
I watched at the Town Hall, our leadership unable to explain our sport to newcomers at the top level. I heard a chain of contradictions in examples that horses shouldn’t shake their heads with enthusiasm after a fantastic effort, while we are sitting in a meeting ostensibly about drug and medication rules. The rulebook is incomprehensible to newcomers and old timers alike. It is nearly impossible to follow, even for people who want to do every single thing they can to respect the sport. The rules in our (many) rulebooks are not simple or easy to understand.
This is not normal. This doesn’t happen in other sports. The NFL Rulebook is 92 pages. With horses adding complexity to our sport, it would be natural to think that our rulebook would be somewhat longer. And it is… it’s 1,290 pages. Of course, that doesn’t include the separate drug & medication rules.
This doesn’t need to happen in our sport. Most people want to follow the rules.
Instead of making clear and comprehensive rules, which at this point would likely require throwing the rulebook in the trash and making a single clear and cohesive document, the tactics seem to be attempting to make a common enemy of trashing our professionals, our sport, our judges, our stewards, and our community.
When we attack each other, the call determining our future is coming from inside the house.
🔗 Continue the full article by Piper Klemm at https://www.theplaidhorse.com/2025/08/11/lets-make-it-easy-to-follow-the-rules/