11/14/2023
Tom Buck Klindt - Is your horse allowed to say no?
I’ve heard more than a few folks answer with an emphatic “hell naw”. A bomb proof horse oughta be compliant and unresistin’ to whatever the rider asks, right? Terms like disrespect, defiance, git used to describe any refusal to submit or obey. I ain’t sayin’ a horse ain’t capable of outright disobedience. I’m sayin’ my experience tells me deliberate recalcitrance is the exception.
I grew up ridin’, breakin’, trainin’, horses. I was taught a philosophy counterintuitive to the prevailin’ mindset of “ride the buck outta ‘em” dominance used by the old time cowboys.
I recall a particular incident gatherin’ cows with a neighbor in Montana mountain country, when my half-mustang mare, Sacajawea, absolutely refused another step in a direction I wanted to go. Nuthin’ could change her mind. Later one of the riders found recent grizzly tracks and s**t, just ahead of where I’d wanted to go. I couldn’t see, hear, or smell a griz nearby, but Sac sure could! That horse was aware of danger I wasn’t.
To me, listenin’ to my horse’s “no’s” isn’t ‘bout who’s in charge. It’s ‘bout allowin’ the same personal autonomy I practice with all relationships. It’s ‘bout consent. I figger consent can’t exist without allowin’ for refusal ‘er withholdin’ of consent.
Man ‘er beast, there’s basic reasons for anyone sayin’ no.
1. Sumthin’ feels scary, dangerous, and fer a prey animal, that’s no joke.
2. It’s expressin’ “I can’t” due to physical limits, pain, lack of confidence, somethin’ else, unknown to me.
3. It’s lack of trust which ain’t the same as disobedience, defiance, ‘er disrespect. If I’m wantin’ my horse to trust me as a peer and partner, I’ve gotta earn, then keep, his trust, plain and simple.
4. My “ask” might not be clear; meanin’ my horse is confused, or misunderstands what and why I’m askin’.
5. Could be somethin’ he just doesn’t want to do, ‘cause he’s tired, feelin’ off his feed, is just not in the mood.
A horse ‘er a human will choose to avoid negative experiences whenever possible. Addin’ pressure to make ‘em do somethin’, (forced compliance) only adds to the negative feelin’s of that experience.
Lettin’ your horse have a voice, listenin’ to him, aren’t gonna teach him to defy ‘er disrespect you. In fact, lettin’ him be “heard” and “seen” help him feel valued, respected, and therefore more willin’.
Groundwork, desensitizing, ridin’, all the trainin’ gits done ‘cause a horse allows it. That consent oughta come from a place of understandin’, communication, and built trust. If he’s allowin’ outta fear, manipulation, force, or demand, it ain’t consent, it’s coercion.
I know, there’s lotsa “yeah, but’s”. I’m not tryin’ to address every nuance, so I’m simplifyin’. I do think buildin’ a consensual relationship makes fer happier and healthier, both horse and hooman.