Caputo Brothers Creamery

Caputo Brothers Creamery Makers of hand-crafted, traditional, authentic, Italian cheeses and cultured milk products. Products Caputo Brothers Creamery is leading the Mozza-revolution!

We make artisan cheeses in the traditional Italian style, developed through years of study and training with master cheesemakers in Italy. This means we use no vinegar or citric acid in our production and all of our cheeses are naturally cultured. We are committed to exclusively sourcing our milk from local, family dairy farms. Our goal is to pay a premium for the milk they produce to create a mor

e sustainable, local dairy economy. In turn, these dairies produce a higher quality, cleaner milk, that allows us to produce a higher quality cheese. All of our farm partners are Animal-Welfare Approved, providing non-GMO feed with access to pasture when available.

Tomorrow night! Only a few seats left!
11/06/2024

Tomorrow night! Only a few seats left!

Join us Nov 7th to learn mozzarella stretching with Caputo Brothers Creamery! Create warm, fresh mozzarella with rich flavor in a few steps.

Congratulations to all of our friends at Scarrs for getting on the top 25 best pizza spots in New York City!            ...
10/30/2024

Congratulations to all of our friends at Scarrs for getting on the top 25 best pizza spots in New York City!
🍕🍕🍕

Troegenator Beer Cheese, our first in the Beer Cheese series, has been crafted with milk fresh from small Pennsylvania d...
10/09/2024

Troegenator Beer Cheese, our first in the Beer Cheese series, has been crafted with milk fresh from small Pennsylvania dairy farms and Tröegs Brewing's legendary Troegenator Double Bock. Slightly sweet with notes of caramel, stone fruit, and a pinch of salt.

Troegenator Beer Cheese is a gouda-style cheese that’s washed in gallons upon gallons of Troegenator, a double bock beer from our friends at Tröegs Brewing Co. in Hershey.

As soon as you crack open this cheese, you’re immediately hit with the smell and sight of beer. Troegenator’s dark color and toasted grain aroma blend with the fat in our cheese to make for a taste comparable to salted caramel popcorn. Be warned, this cheese is dangerously good.

Until end of day Sunday, October 13th, enjoy 25% off Troegenator Beer Cheese!
https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/collections/cheeses/products/troegenator-beer-cheese

Local dairies, local beer, local good 🍻The phrase that started it all...If you happen to spend any time on our website o...
10/09/2024

Local dairies, local beer, local good 🍻

The phrase that started it all...

If you happen to spend any time on our website or plant in Spring Grove, you’ll learn quickly that we’re all about supporting our local farms. You may have also picked up that we make Italian-style cheese. So what compelled us to break tradition and go gouda?

GIANT Food Stores first approached us and Tröegs with a desire to collaborate and make a cheese that would stock shelves in not just a small handful of GIANT stores, but in ALL of them. While we’re all about true Italian representation, an opportunity to sell literal tons of cheese comes with the opportunity to buy tons of milk from local farms. Plus we get to work with beer! How could we say no?

Join us on November 7th at South County for a live-action mozzarella class! Doors open at 5:30, the class is 6 to 7:30!F...
10/07/2024

Join us on November 7th at South County for a live-action mozzarella class!
Doors open at 5:30, the class is 6 to 7:30!

For more information, and to purchase tickets click below!

We hope to see you there!

Join us Nov 7th to learn mozzarella stretching with Caputo Brothers Creamery! Create warm, fresh mozzarella with rich flavor in a few steps.

On the topic of Oktoberfest, It all started with a chance reunion of our company owners at a local festival.  Though the...
10/03/2024

On the topic of Oktoberfest,

It all started with a chance reunion of our company owners at a local festival. Though the Caputos met Ben years ago when the creamery was just getting started, our paths hadn't crossed in a few years. As we talked through surviving COVID and the difficulties of running small family businesses while trying to raise our families, an idea started to form. What if we put our cheese together with Big Hill's Standard Cider? By Monday of the following week, we had some hard cider on hand and the cheesemaking team got busy making scratch batches of what would become our next great cheese!

We start by mulling the hard cider with sticks of cinnamon, whole cloves, and nutmeg, before washing our gouda-style cheese curds. After the aging process is completed in our caves, we put the wheels into the smoker for a long, cool, infusion of applewood smoke.

The resulting flavor is all things sweet, creamy, salty, and smokey! We think it is the perfect addition to any celebration and a great representation of all Central Pennsylvania has to offer. We think it pairs perfectly with any seasonal hard cider, but of course, we will be eating ours with a Big Hill Ciderworks in hand...and we hope you will too!

Until end of day Sunday, October 6th, enjoy 25% off Big Hill Ciderworks smoked cider cheese!

Shop now!
https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/collections/cheeses/products/smoked-bighill-ciderworks-mulled-cider-cheese

We will have a booth at South County's Oktoberfest this Saturday! Come out between 12 & 4 for great beer, local vendors,...
10/02/2024

We will have a booth at South County's Oktoberfest this Saturday! Come out between 12 & 4 for great beer, local vendors, music, and more!
Stop out and say hi! 🍻

Happy Oktoberfest! 🍻While we know traditional Oktoberfest is held in September to the first Sunday in October, we are ce...
10/01/2024

Happy Oktoberfest! 🍻

While we know traditional Oktoberfest is held in September to the first Sunday in October, we are celebrating the whole month of October!
For the entire month of October, we're offering 25% off our beer cheese sampler!
Which includes 8oz of
- Mad Elf
- Troegenator
- Perpetual
- Grand Cacao
Share with friends, pair with the matching beers, create a charcuterie board for any get-together from tailgating to game nights!
Shop now -> https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/collections/cheeses/products/beer-cheese-sampler

Come see us at the 3rd annual L'Italia Festival at Lititz Springs Park, this Saturday, 9/21!  We'll be there, along with...
09/18/2024

Come see us at the 3rd annual L'Italia Festival at Lititz Springs Park, this Saturday, 9/21! We'll be there, along with Curata Travel - stop by & say hi, and pick up some cheese!!
Learn more: https://www.lititz.it/

Countdown to L'Italia Festival: 4 Days to Go! 🎉

🗓️ Saturday, 9/21
⏰ 10 am - 5 pm
📍 Lititz Springs Park

Get ready for a slice of Italy right here in Lititz!

🍝 Mouthwatering Italian cuisine
🎨 Unique crafts
🎭 Fun activities for all ages

The best part? Admission is FREE! 🆓

Bring your family and friends for an unforgettable day of Italian culture and community spirit.

Don't miss out on this bellissimo event! 🌟

"

Reminder!!!END OF SUMMER SALE! 🌊☀🏄‍♀️We are sad to see summer go, so as an ode to summer we are running a sale through L...
09/01/2024

Reminder!!!
END OF SUMMER SALE! 🌊☀🏄‍♀️
We are sad to see summer go, so as an ode to summer we are running a sale through Labor Day weekend! With the holiday weekend coming up, we wanted to make sure you had a chance to stock up!
We're offering 50% off the following
- Virtual classes!
- Beer cheeses!
- Provola!
- Chesapeake gouda!
Automatically will be applied at checkout. It cannot be applied to prior purchases, wholesale orders, or other sale items. Through 11:59p.m. on 9/2/23.
Please note: we will be closed on Monday, 9/2 and curbside pickup will not be available.

NEW! NEW! NEW!We have brand-new packaging for our whey-based fresh ricotta! Be the first to try out our brand-new packag...
08/30/2024

NEW! NEW! NEW!

We have brand-new packaging for our whey-based fresh ricotta!

Be the first to try out our brand-new packaging!

END OF SUMMER SALE! 🌊☀️🏄‍♀️We are sad to see summer go, so as an ode to summer we are running a sale through Labor Day w...
08/27/2024

END OF SUMMER SALE! 🌊☀️🏄‍♀️
We are sad to see summer go, so as an ode to summer we are running a sale through Labor Day weekend! With the holiday weekend coming up, we wanted to make sure you had a chance to stock up!

We're offering 50% off the following
- Virtual classes!
- Beer cheeses!
- Provola!
- Chesapeake gouda!


Automatically will be applied at checkout. It cannot be applied to prior purchases, wholesale orders, or other sale items. Through 11:59p.m. on 9/2/23.
Please note: we will be closed on Monday, 9/2 and curbside pickup will not be available.

It's Monday morning, the kids are heading back to school...what better time to daydream about your perfect Italian vacat...
08/26/2024

It's Monday morning, the kids are heading back to school...what better time to daydream about your perfect Italian vacation?? Scroll through our 2025 tours here and make it a reality!
https://curatatravel.com/pages/2025-tours

Address

245 N Main Street
Spring Grove, PA
17362

Opening Hours

Monday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday 9:30am - 4:30pm
Friday 9:30am - 4:30pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Caputo Brothers Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Caputo Brothers Creamery:

Videos

Share

Our Story

We're cultured & so is our cheese! We're one of the only cheesemakers producing a cultured cheese curd that can be used to stretch mozz, burrata, and other pasta filata cheeses. A family-owned cheesemaking business, with a retail shop (open M-F, 9a.m.-5p.m.)