Caputo Brothers Creamery

01/07/2025

We just announced our tours for 2026!! Which one is catching your eye...?

12/16/2024

SHIPPING DEADLINE! Order by noon this Wednesday for the best chance of your order or gift arriving by Christmas!
https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/collections/all

And don't forget - 20% off all cheeses (including cheese gift boxes!), 50% off of Virtual Classes, and buy one-get one free on our 4- and 8-packs of frozen mozzarella curd so you can stretch your own fresh mozz at home!

Whether you're looking for a gift for your favorite foodie or looking to impress your guests with incredible cheeses on your charcuterie board - we've got something for everyone!

12/14/2024

🎉 The Cheese Deals are still going strong! 🧀

The clock is ticking, and these irresistible cheese deals won’t last long! Get in on the action before December 18th to ensure you get your order in time for Christmas delivery — perfect for holiday parties, cozy gatherings, or simply stocking up your freezer!

🧀 50% Off Virtual Classes
Want to wow your friends and family with your cheese knowledge this season? Now’s your chance to join our Virtual Cheese Classes at half the price! Whether you’re a cheese novice or a seasoned aficionado, you’ll learn the secrets of the perfect cheese pairings and the art of cheesemaking, all from the comfort of home. It’s the gift that keeps on giving!

🧀 Buy One, Get One Free on Frozen Mozzarella Curd
Craving that warm fresh mozzarella? Our Frozen Mozzarella Curd is flying off the shelves, and for a limited time, it’s Buy One, Get One Free! Stock up for your holiday recipes — pizza, pasta, and so much more. Your freezer (and your taste buds) will thank you.

12/14/2024

Are you ready to take your taste buds on an unforgettable adventure? 🧀
With our Cheese of the Month Club, each month brings a new, carefully curated selection of artisanal cheeses straight to your door! Whether you’re a seasoned cheese connoisseur or a newbie looking to explore new flavors, this subscription is your passport to indulge in a taste of Italy.
https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/collections/gift-ideas/products/cheese-of-the-month-club

What’s Included?
Exclusive, Handpicked Cheeses: Discover unique cheeses you won’t find in stores, from fresh ricotta to aged gouda and everything in between.
Surprise and Delight: No two months are the same! Every delivery is an exciting surprise, with cheeses selected from different styles, and flavor profiles.
Support Small Producers: By joining, you’re not just treating yourself — you’re supporting small, passionate cheesemakers who craft their products with love and care.

Why You’ll Love It:

Variety: Say goodbye to the same old grocery store varieties. Each month brings new flavors, textures, and experiences.
Convenience: No need to leave your home — we deliver the finest cheeses straight to your door, packed to stay fresh and ready to enjoy.
Education: Learn about the cheeses you’re tasting with fun facts and pairing tips, turning you into a cheese expert in no time!

12/13/2024

Let Us Handle Your Gifting Needs! 🎁
Looking for the perfect gift? We’ve got you covered!
Simply fill out the attached spreadsheet, and we’ll take care of the rest—creating personalized gift notes, ensuring timely delivery, and ensuring your gifts are nothing short of extraordinary.
From cheese lovers to master chefs, we’ve got a selection that’s perfect for every taste and occasion. Let us bring a smile to their face with the perfect gift, delivered with care!

12/08/2024

MOZZARELLA MONDAY?!?!
Join us on TOMORROW at noon on instagram for our first ever Mozzarella Monday!
Join Rynn & Kyle at noon for an exciting live session where they’ll be stretching fresh mozzarella and sharing delicious, festive ideas for your holiday gatherings! They'll be showcasing fun and creative recipes using frozen curd (currently on sale!), inspired by their very first trip to Italy—complete with a nod to the vibrant flavors of Calabria. Whether you're looking to wow your guests with something unique or add a special touch to your get-togethers, Rynn & Kyle have you covered. Don't miss out on this chance to get some culinary inspiration and learn new tricks just in time for the season’s celebrations!

12/08/2024

12/02/2024

Buy one get one 50% off VECCHIO!
Ricotta Salata, or Vecchio, starts with a whey-based ricotta that’s pressed, salted, and aged for at least six weeks. The cheese team carefully monitors each wheel to ensure proper rind development, making this a uniquely well-tended cheese.

Thanks to local milk, Vecchio is richer in moisture than traditional Ricotta Salata, allowing it to develop a special rind typically seen only in southern Sicily. The cheese has a firm texture and a complex flavor profile—salty with a hint of sweetness, a custardy aroma, and a funky blue rind that adds earthy notes.

Often used as a substitute for Parmigiano Reggiano in southern Italy, this versatile cheese can be grated, sliced, or used as a filling in pasta. It's perfect for topping dishes like fresh tomatoes with balsamic and basil, adding to eggs, or serving on a cheeseboard with honey. Vecchio is a must-have for any kitchen!

12/02/2024

TODAY ONLY, enjoy 50% off all of the above-mentioned products when you spend over 50$ on those products!

12/01/2024

Buy one get one 50% off CHESAPEAKE GOUDA
Your favorite Gouda meets your favorite seafood spice! We have not only mixed this popular spice into the curd before pressing, but we have rubbed the outside of each wheel with this delicious goodness!

11/30/2024

Buy one get one 50% off
SMOKED BIGHILL CIDERWORKS MULLED CIDER CHEESE
It all started with a chance reunion of our company owners at a local festival. Though the Caputos met Ben years ago when the creamery was just getting started, our paths hadn't crossed in a few years. As we talked through surviving COVID and the difficulties of running small family businesses while trying to raise our families, an idea started to form. What if we put our cheese together with Big Hill's Standard Cider? By Monday of the following week, we had some hard cider on hand and the cheesemaking team got busy making scratch batches of what would become our next great cheese!

We start by mulling the hard cider with sticks of cinnamon, whole cloves, and nutmeg, before washing our gouda-style cheese curds. After the aging process is completed in our caves, we put the wheels into the smoker for a long, cool, infusion of applewood smoke.

The resulting flavor is all things sweet, creamy, salty, and smokey! We think it is the perfect addition to any celebration and a great representation of all Central Pennsylvania has to offer. We think it pairs perfectly with any seasonal hard cider, but of course, we will be eating ours with a Big Hill Ciderworks in hand...and we hope you will too!

11/30/2024

SMALL BUSINESS SATURDAY!
TODAY ONLY, enjoy 50% off all of the products mentioned below when you spend over 50$ on those products!

11/29/2024

Buy one get one 50% off GOUDA RISERVA!
If you've enjoyed our Giving Gouda, we think you'll LOVE our Gouda Riserva! Aged for 3 months in our aging cave, this version is firmer with a great, sharp flavor. It's already a huge hit with our staff!

11/29/2024

Let's create cheese!
TODAY ONLY, enjoy 50% off all curd products when you spend over 50$ on curd products!

11/28/2024

Happy Thanksgiving! 🦃❤️
All of us here at CBC hope you all have an amazing Thanksgiving; we are grateful for all of you & your continued love & support!
Buy one get one 50% off GIVING GOUDA!
While the red wax-coated Gouda you see in supermarkets is iconic, "Gouda" actually refers to a style of cheesemaking. This particular Gouda-style cheese is made using a "washed curd" process, where the curds are washed with water to remove excess lactose, resulting in a sweeter, milder flavor. After being pressed into a round mold and brined for 3 days, it is aged for a few weeks.
"The Giving Gouda" was created in late 2020 as part of a charitable initiative to support the Central Pennsylvania Food Bank. For every pound of cheese purchased online, a pound of Gouda was donated. Thanks to generous customers, over 13,500 pounds of cheese were donated to the food bank.

11/28/2024

Just a reminder that we will be closed on Thanksgiving, and Black Friday!
We hope you all have an amazing holiday! ❤

11/28/2024

Enjoy buy one, get one 50% off our PROVOLA RISERVA!

https://caputobrotherscreamery.com/products/provola-riserva

Provolone, meaning "big, aged mozzarella" in Italian, is made by stretching naturally fermented curds by hand and shaping them into a traditional tubular form. After cooling, the cheese is aged in brine for about 6 months. As it ages, it loses moisture, developing a firm texture with a slight grit (similar to young Parmigiano Reggiano) and a sharp, nutty flavor. The more mature version, *Riserva*, is a refined sibling of Provola, perfect for slicing on a cheeseboard with spicy cured meats and jams, or for grating onto pizza and pasta.