01/06/2026
“I want a guard dog for protection.”
Okay. Let’s slow that down for a second, because I hear that a lot, and most people don’t think about the weight of the decision they make when choosing a guardian breed.
Let me ask you something.
When you say guard dog, what do you actually picture happening?
Do you mean a dog that lets you know something’s off?
A dog that looks intimidating enough that most people won’t try anything?
A dog that might step in and stop someone?
Or a dog that makes its own call and handles the situation without waiting on you?
Because those are very different dogs.
Most people think they want a dog willing to act if needed. But when you really unpack that, that’s usually not what they mean.
What they usually mean is presence.
Deterrence.
Something that makes people think twice.
They usually do not mean they want to live with a powerful, serious animal that makes decisions, isn’t socially flexible, and requires excellent handling every single day. That’s a big responsibility most households don’t consider.
A guard dog is a lot like a weapon.
Not in a scary way. In a responsibility way.
Weapons require knowledge, skill, handling, and knowing when to use them and when not to. Owning one doesn’t automatically make you safer. Misunderstanding one absolutely makes things worse.
Same thing with serious guardian dogs.
There’s a difference between a watch dog and a guard dog.
A watch dog alerts.
A guard dog engages.
And there’s a difference between a dog that holds a threat and a dog that decides what happens next.
A Bullmastiff, for example, was meant to stop and hold poachers when they found them.
Dogs like Bernese Mountain Dogs, Bullmastiffs, Rottweilers from stable lines, Great Danes, and Newfoundlands.
These dogs are generally easier for most people to live with. More socially flexible. More forgiving. They provide presence and deterrence without needing to make heavy decisions on their own.
Dogs like Gamprs, Tibetan Mastiffs, Caucasian Shepherds, Central Asian Shepherds, Filas, Presa Canarios, and the Cane Corso
These dogs tend to be more aloof, more deliberate, and more independent. They often think twice before responding to commands and take their role very seriously.
That doesn’t make them bad dogs.
It makes them high-responsibility dogs.
So here’s the real question.
Do you want a dog that fits easily into your everyday life
or a dog that takes protection very seriously?
Most people don’t actually want a dog that makes decisions for them.
They want a dog that buys them time. Alerts them. Looks the part.
And that’s okay.
The problem is choosing dogs based on the idea of protection without thinking through the responsibility that comes with it.
I get compliments about my Gampr Bear all of the time, people tell me he’s incredible. And he is, he’s got a stable temperament but I put in so much work to help him become the incredible dog you see. He is a serious guardian at his core and my job is to responsibly handle him every day. It’s a lot of work.