05/20/2025
Thinking about adopting a rescue dog? Discover the high points and potential challenges of adopting from a shelter or rescue to help decide if it's the right path for you.
Today is National Dog Rescue Day: a chance to honor second chances, wagging tails, and the big-hearted humans who open their homes to dogs in need.
I have fostered for, volunteered at and adopted dogs from shelters and rescues and also spent months finding a responsible breeder for my beloved spaniel Ziva—I understand the complexity of the question: "Is adopting a rescue dog right for me?"
This post isn't here to judge your path. It's here to help you make an informed, compassionate decision.
🐾 The Highs Points of Adopting a Rescue Dog
1. You're saving a life.
Perhaps the most compelling reason: by adopting a rescue dog, you're giving a home to a dog who may have been abandoned, surrendered, or overlooked. Many have endured hardship and your kindness rewrites their story.
2. Rescues often have adult dogs.
If puppy training isn’t your dream, adult dogs from shelters are often house-trained, socialized, and ready to settle into a home.
3. Adoption fees are usually lower.
Rescue fees often include vaccinations, microchipping, and spaying/neutering, making them more affordable than the cost of buying a puppy from a breeder.
4. You're supporting a cycle of compassion.
By adopting from a shelter or rescue, you're making space for the next dog in need and there are so very many in need. Spaces are limited in shelters and rescue and many never get a second chance.
🐾 The Challenges of Adopting a Rescue Dog
1. Unknown history can mean surprises.
Some rescue dogs come with emotional or behavorial baggage. It's not their fault—but it does mean adopters need patience, experience, or professional support.
2. Compatibility isn't guaranteed.
You may not find your ideal breed or temperament in a local shelter, or the right match might take time. Some rescue dogs may not be suitable for homes with children, other pets, or certain lifestyles.
3. Limited early life insights.
With many rescue dogs, especially strays, you may not know much about their early development—which can impact training, health, or temperament.
That being said even puppies from the most reputable of breeders can have challenges. When it comes top dogs and puppies nothing is ever guaranteed and many pure bred dogs find themselves in rescues and shelters.
When Is a Reputable Breeder a Better Fit?
In some cases, especially for people with specific needs or working dog requirements, a reputable, ethical breeder may be a more suitable option. This was the case when I welcomed Ziva, my spaniel, into my life. I carefully researched and waited months to find a breeder who prioritized health, temperament, and ethical practices. Then once I was accepted onto the waiting list I waited months for Ziva to be born.
Choosing a reputable breeder is never a shortcut—it's a long-term investment in responsibility, research, and lifelong care.
Whether you're adopting a rescue dog or working with a breeder, the most important question is: Can I meet this dog’s needs for the next 10–15 years, emotionally and physically?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. What matters most is intention, preparation, and compassion.
On this National Dog Rescue Day, let’s celebrate the dogs who’ve found their second (or third) chance and honor every human who chooses to love, train, and protect them, no matter where they came from.