
10/14/2022
* BUT PRESSURE AND PUNISHEMENT ARE NATURAL WAYS OF COMMUNICATION BETWEEN HORSES *
This argument is very popular amongst people who chose to use negative reinforcement /punishment as the main way to get the desired behaviours from horses.
This statement is partially right - but it's not just horses who adjust their behaviour in a response to aversive stimuli, every single living being does. Part of survival is to be able to detect and avoid /escape from threatening stimuli.
Here is the thing: the aversive pressure used in communication between horses is only used for NEGATIVE interactions.
The agonistic interactions communicate that one horse is not happy with whatever the other horse is doing and wants to create in another horse distance (distance increasing behaviours) .
And that's all - it's not there to look for particular behaviours, it's not there for prolonged times, it's not there to control every movement. It's only there as a swift action to say "hey, get out of my way!". It doesn't create strong bonds or positive relationships - right the opposite. It doesn't trap a horse at the end of a lead rope, in the roundpen, in the school or between the whips. It's not even a big part of a daily life (unless the horse's needs are not being met) as in healthy groups of horses positive interactions dominate because horses are peaceful animals.
And most importantly it doesn't take the autonomy away.
A horse on the receiving end is free to move away from the oppressor and not engaged with him again but within the human -horse interactions this freedom is taken away .
A horse is made to endure the escalation of pressure and/or punishment multiple times often for an hour or longer. It's not natural for a horse to keep on reengaging with something that sends threatening signals to his nervous systems and activates avoidance and escape behaviours.