07/22/2026
No one is entitled to a right of refusal. They are not legally enforcable. However, they are kind.
This creamery refused to sell back to the breeder despite being offered more than they had paid in the first place. They cared more about top dollar than they cared about the goats ending up is a good place. That's incredibly icky to me.
This wasn't a "we need to sell because we are closing the doors" issue, this is a "the person that loves these does wants them back, but we refuse" issue.
Yes, they were legally within their rights because livestock is recognized as property, not sentient beings. If you would refuse a good home with a breeder that is willing to pay the value of the animal just for the "maybe" chance at getting a higher price please unfollow me.
I practice what I preach. I have 5 girls that came with a first right of refusal from their breeders. I fully intend on following through with that offer when they are to leave my farm. That is not a moral lines I am willing to cross. A good steward cares about animals, even after they are sold.
I rarely ask for it with my girls. In fact, I have only ever asked for first refusal with one goat. Once they leave my farm, I understand that they control what happens. However, I certainly hope that if the day happens that they move her along, I would have the chance to bring her back here on the homestead.
Whew! That was very stressful and crazy but we are the other side now and I can finally take a deep breath. I unfortunately was not able to bring all 6 home today, but I did get 4 and thatβs a huge win for me! One was never brought to the auction so I had no chance at her sadly. The other five were brought in small groups. I was able to be the winning bid on three and the other two were bought by other ppl. After the sale the office ladies at Unadilla helped me by contacting the one buyer and he offered me her for just a tad bit more money so I bought her too. I could not find the buyer of Ohana sadly so I was unable to get her back. Pictured is Jubilee, Scout, and Pirouette. This was taken before I bought Petal back. I just want to send out a HUGE thankyou to everyone for your support, well wishes and encouragement the last couple of days. These girls will need a lot of groceries and deworming. More pics and updates to come.