11/11/2025
Rethinking “Rank”: Understanding Dog Interactions Beyond Dominance
For a long time, people interpreted dog interactions through the idea of rank or dominance — assuming one dog is “alpha” and the other is “submissive.”
But modern behavioural science has shown that this way of thinking is outdated and oversimplified.
When dogs interact, they’re not trying to climb a social ladder — they’re navigating complex emotional and social dynamics. Their behaviour can reflect:
Confidence and emotional state – A dog that stands tall or uses stillness may be uncertain or anxious, not “in charge.”
Context – Is there a valuable resource around (like a toy or owner attention)? Are both dogs comfortable in this space?
Communication style – Just like people, dogs have different social skills. Some are more assertive or forward, others more subtle.
Learning history – Past experiences shape how a dog responds to others. A dog that’s been told off for greeting too eagerly may appear “submissive,” when it’s really showing caution.
It’s also vital to remember that how a dog feels physically and emotionally will influence their social behaviour.
Pain, discomfort, or underlying health issues can make dogs less tolerant or more avoidant.
Recent stress — such as changes at home, vet visits, loud noises, or multiple challenging experiences in a short period — can leave them with less capacity to cope calmly with other dogs.
When we focus only on rank, we risk missing the real message — how a dog feels. Understanding that behaviour is driven by emotion allows us to respond with empathy and to support both dogs in feeling safe and confident.
Next time you see two dogs interacting, try asking:
“Who’s feeling comfortable here?”
"Who’s managing space and movement?”
“Are both dogs enjoying this?”
These questions tell us far more than who’s “the boss.”
As a Clinical Animal Behaviourist (APBC, ABTC), my goal is always to help owners look beyond labels and understand the rich, subtle world of canine communication — where trust, safety, and emotion matter most.
www.paulinewhittaker.co.uk