30/12/2022
Why not follow Pack rules with dogs?
The rank reduction programme is based on the dominance theory. It is used to lower a dogs status to stop behaviour that is believed to be caused by the dog is seemingly being dominant. The rrp enforces the believed pack rules onto a dog who is being “dominant” to make him see you as the alpha, thereby making him submissive to you and ultimately stopping his “dominant” behaviour.
The problem with this is that the believed pack rules are not even followed by wolves, wolves do not live by dominance hierarchies. Wolves live vary harmoniously and the pack consists of mostly the parents and offspring. They work together and do not fight over rank, the males leave the pack and start their own packs, they do not fight their father for his spot, or any other male for theirs. The males find a female and start their own pack.
So if not even wolves follow these pack rules, why would dogs?
As studies on feral dogs show dogs do not follow these rules either. They don’t even follow the real pack dynamic. One dog will mate with multiple dogs, the bitch would raise her pups all by herself and they do not hunt. As we can see with wolves they form breading pairs and mate with the same wolf for life, they will raise their pups together and will work together to hunt for food.
As we can see, dogs do not live under a pack, dominance based social structure. So why would we then apply rules based off of this on an animal who does not understand it? That is why we don’t. Seeing they do not understand or work under dominance hierarchies, labelling their behaviour as dominant simply does not make sense. So there is then no use to applying a RRP.
Seeing that it teaches the dog nothing, and at best might make the dog depressed witch may make it look like it worked. When you stop applying the rules assuming you have solved the problem, you return to normal. There is one problem with this, the actual behavioural problem was never solved, so it will simply resurface. This means that either you have to continue the rrp forever, or call it. So all in all ineffective at least.
How is it dangerous to apply?
There are many reasons. First would be that it could break your relationship with your dog. When we look at the rules of the rrp we can see that it ends up removing a lot in your dog’s life that he previously enjoyed, this will cause frustration for your dog, and will cause him to become protective over the resource or try harder to get it, which may cause aggression. Or he will become depressed making it look like the rrp worked. Seeing that you are the one who is withholding these things from your dog, it will ruin your relationship with him as he will associate you with the removal of a valuable thing to him. Another aspect to consider is that by removing these things from your dog you can end up getting hurt because your dog might bite due to resource guarding.
Second it will not give much room for loving your dog. So you will end up treating your dog like a prisoner and not be able to enjoy your dog. All of us probably love our dogs, and we want to be able to enjoy time with them, hug them, cuddle them, play with them and have a dog who is happy to see us. So you will no longer have best friend but instead a slave. Your dog will also not be able to create a trusting bond with you because you no longer do these things.
Let’s look at some of the common aspects of a RRP:
Owners should eat first:
The basis for this is the misconception that the Alpha wolf would eat first, witch they don’t. Besides the fact that it is based on a myth, incorporating it would be difficult as everyone higher than the dog will need to eat before him. Ultimately your dog learns nothing from this from a behavioural standpoint.
Dogs are not allowed on furniture:
The thought here is that by allowing the dog to lay at the same spot as you, the dog would think he is at the same status as you are higher. In reality the only problem that can come from this could be resource guarding, which is not dominance.
Don’t play tug:
“Alpha” wolves or those of a higher status are believed to always win when tugging on meat. In reality tugging on meat by wolves is a combined effort to tear flesh apart, and has nothing to do with dominance. There are also studies that reveal that dogs play differently with dogs than they do with people. It revealed that with people it is more of play and not a contest.
Dogs should not go through doorways first:
Here it is thought that the “Alpha” would go in front. This is possible but mostly because they are more experienced and know where to go so they lead the pack, it is not dominance related. This is also not practical, imagine it rains? This may well still be something we teach as it is better to not have your dog pull you through doorways.
Dogs can’t lay on the top of the stairs:
It is believed that the “Alpha” would always lay on a higher surface than the rest of the pack. This is once again has nothing to do with status but rather safety as it provides a better vantage point.
Understanding how they can seem to work.
By removing something the dog likes after the dog has come to expect it is negative punishment. This can cause the dog to have the same reaction as they would with aversive punishment. Random punishment can cause the dog to feel helpless, cause conflict, response suppression and even depression. The RRP will end up punishing the dog randomly and therefor will have these affects and it will seem as though the dog is calmer.
Different dogs and breeds will view different things as important and have different thresholds. So the RRP will end up having a different effect on different dogs. Dogs will display resource guarding over things they see as valuable, this can be perceived as dominance and by taking that away the dog will not be able to resource guard as it does not have access to that resource. Dogs will also learn what works to keep their resource, this may also seem like dominance when it is actually a learnt behaviour. In actuality we should find out what is valuable, why and why the dog feels the need to guard it and fix that, not just remove resources.