What are the opening hours?

Wednesday 9am - 5pm Saturday 9am - 5pm Sunday 9am - 5pm

Hearty Horse Cookie Co.

Home
United States
New York, NY
Hearty Horse Cookie Co.

Hearty Horse Cookie Co. Bringing your equine besties the cutest and most delicious treats. Designs change with the season so check back soon to see what is new!
(4)

All treats are made to order and are USEF and FEI safe.

10/11/2023

Last day to order for guaranteed delivery before Halloween! Spooky scary skeleton unicorns included in every size box!
heartyhorsecookieco.com

09/29/2023

pumpkin spice and everything nice 🥧
Find these and other adorable seasonal treats in our Fall Mini, Medium, and Mega Mystery Boxes!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

09/29/2023

Spooky Season is upon us 👻 the shop is reopen and we have 3 sizes of mystery boxes available to convince your favorite horse that there are no goblins in the corner and the breeze isn’t a super charger! Free drop off in Nassau County with shipping all over the USA!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

06/18/2023

☀️It’s summer time and the treats are divine! Celebrate the warm weather with your horse’s favorite sweet treats! ☀️Mini, Medium, and Mega Boxes In Stock Now and this weekend only, all Mega Boxes come with a free gift!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

03/04/2023

Spring cookies are in the oven and will be on the site soon! We are looking forward to the warmer weather and pretty pastels hitting our shelves this week!

01/29/2023

❤️ mini, medium, and mega valentines boxes still available for 2 more days!
❤️ nationwide shipping and Long Island local pick up available
❤️ freshly baked to order so your horse or pony is only getting the very best
❤️ USEF/ FEI safe ingredients
❤️ picky eater approved

heartyhorsecookieco.com

01/24/2023

❤️🤍💖🤍❤️
Valentine’s Treats are beginning to ship out! Available in mini, medium, and mega sized boxes to keep all of your equine valentines feeling the love 💕 order by 1/31 for guaranteed holiday delivery!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

01/03/2023

Mini, Medium, and Mega boxes are back in stock with a great mix of donuts, cookies, and muffins! Select your theme or choose the seasonal selection to get the trendiest treats of the season!

11/29/2022

✨ CYBER MONDAY ✨
final hours for 10% off with promo code happyholidays at checkout!

holiday variety boxes of muffins available in 3 sizes and our favorite chilly weather cookie collection are live online now!

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

Free Long Island Pick Up available!

11/28/2022

Chilly Weather Cookie Collection is back! The sweetest gift for your barn besties and the perfect size to slide into your horses stall stockings!

10% off today for Cyber Monday with code happyholidays at checkout!

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

05/30/2022

🇺🇸TODAY ONLY🇺🇸
Memorial Day Sale
🇺🇸15% off site wide🇺🇸

Use code : hellosummer22

05/22/2022

Final day to order before we take a little summer break!

Muffin mystery boxes are a great way to stock up for the season! Lots of cute tanks, tees, and other goodies available!

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

📸:

05/20/2022

final weekend to stock up before hearty horse cookie co. closes for summer break!

order your birthday cakes, tanks, sun shirts, and your horses’ favorite treats today!

mixed muffin boxes are available in three different sizes offer discounts up to 15% on sweet treats for your favorite ponies!

As always, thank you all for supporting my small business, each and every order puts the biggest smile on my face so thank you and your ponies!

☁️☀️🌸☀️🌺☀️🌻☀️☁️

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

05/20/2022

We are loving baking and making all of these muffins ❤️💕🤍 all pending orders are baked, decorated and cooling to prepare for their voyage in a few days! Keep an eye on your email for tracking numbers and pickup options!

Didn’t get to order yet? Our muffin mystery boxes are still available for a few days!

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

05/19/2022

05/18/2022

New Luau Drizzle Muffins 🌸

Found only in our Muffin Mystery Boxes!

Only a few boxes left in stock! Order today!

05/11/2022

Quite a few birthday cakes rolling out of our bakery this week!

Did you know our birthday cakes are scored on the bottom to make them easier to snap and share with your pony NEIGHbors 🐴🎂

05/06/2022

Mixed Muffin Mystery Boxes
www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

$25 Mini (5% Savings)
$50 Medium (10% Savings)
$100 Mega (15% Savings)

Discontinued designs for a discounted rate! Boxes are freshly baked and can include toppers and designs from sunflowers to Santa, and everything in between! Great time to stock up on your horses favorite treats!

05/05/2022

which muffin designs will be in your mixed muffin mystery box?

heartyhorsecookieco.com

Mini $25
Medium $50
Mega $100

05/05/2022

🌸 Spring Cleaning 🌸
🧁 Mixed Muffin Mystery Boxes 🧁

Discontinued designs at a discounted rate! Head to our site for up to 15% off muffins! Freshly baked Hearty Horse Muffins with toppers from every season and set!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

Limited Quantities Available!

04/19/2022

🛍 SOLD OUT 🛍

While I figured 848 cookies, muffins, and donuts all baked and decorated with love would last a little while, our two and four-legged fans have cleared out the shop in less than a month!

Thank you to all of my customers for your purchases, pictures, and hearty horse pride!

Please keep an eye on the page for our next restock and follow our sister company for updates on the hearty horse brand 🐴

03/18/2022

Did someone order muffins?
🧁🤍🧁🤍🧁🤍🧁

192 of these decorated little cuties are headed to the post office bright and early tomorrow!

(Once they’re fully dry)

Keep an eye on your inbox for tracking numbers!

03/14/2022

Don’t miss our best sale of the season!

Just a few hours left for buy three get one free!

Use code springintosavings to stock up on your horses favorite goodies!

Free Long Island pickup and Shipping all over the US

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

03/13/2022

Introducing our Flower Power Muffins. A pack of 12 warm pink and orange hues ready to welcome the warmer spring weather! These little cuties are added to the shop just in time for our Buy 3 Get 1 Free Sale ending at midnight!

Use Code springintosavings to get any item for free!

Sale includes all items on our site

03/12/2022

✨BUY 3 GET 1 FREE✨

www.heartyhorsecookieco.com

this weekend only use code springintosavings to shake off the last bit of winter with hearty horse cookie co!

Sale includes treats and merch so it’s the perfect time to stock up for Spring!

As always, thank you for supporting my small business dreams 🤍

Free Long Island Pick Up Available!

03/11/2022

New treats aren’t the only thing we added to the shop this week!

Check out all the hearty horse merch to accompany your horse’s favorite treats and help me grow my tiny little business!

Each and every sale brings a smile and celebration so a huge thank you to all of my followers, customers, friends who share my posts, and ponies who love my treats!

03/10/2022

☘️MARCH TREATS ARE HERE ☘️

Get your favorite spring time goodies! Seasonal selections ready to ship in time for St. Paddy’s Day! Lots of favorites back in stock and lots of colorful goodies to bring in the warmer weather!

heartyhorsecookieco.com

03/05/2022

Big Red is ready for the major March treat and apparel reveal!

New muffins, cookies, merch and more! Keep an eye on our pages on Saturday 3/12 for new releases, sales and discount codes!

02/26/2022

Scoop up some butterscotch blossoms in our Hello Spring Cookie Collection!
🌼🌸🌼🌸🌼🌸🌼🌸
Available now on our website heartyhorsecookieco.com

📸: .equestrian

Address

New York, NY

Opening Hours

Wednesday	9am - 5pm
Saturday	9am - 5pm
Sunday	9am - 5pm

Telephone

+19174766515

Website

http://heartyhorsecookieco.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hearty Horse Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Videos

Final days to save with our Mixed Muffin Mystery Boxes! One of a kind and discontinued designs at a discount. The more you buy the more you save with 5%-15% off typical treat prices depending on size of box! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horse #horsesofinstagram #gourmethorsetreats #horsetreats #horsecookies #equestrian #hunterjumper #equitation #jumpers #foxhunting #hunterpace #dressage #sidesaddle #saddleseat #western #barrelracing #trailride #polebending #teampenning #polo #rodeo #plussizeequestrian

New Luau Drizzle Muffins 🌸 Found only in our Muffin Mystery Boxes! Only a few boxes left in stock! Order today! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horse #horsesofinstagram #gourmethorsetreats #horsetreats #horsecookies #equestrian #hunterjumper #equitation #jumpers #foxhunting #hunterpace #dressage #sidesaddle #saddleseat #western #barrelracing #trailride #polebending #teampenning #polo #rodeo #plussizeequestrian

Quite a few birthday cakes rolling out of our bakery this week! Did you know our birthday cakes are scored on the bottom to make them easier to snap and share with your pony NEIGHbors 🐴🎂 #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horse #horsesofinstagram #gourmethorsetreats #horsetreats #horsecookies #equestrian #hunterjumper #equitation #jumpers #foxhunting #hunterpace #dressage #sidesaddle #saddleseat #western #barrelracing #trailride #polebending #teampenning #polo #rodeo #plussizeequestrian #horsebirthdaycake #ponyparty #horsebirthdayparty

Did someone order muffins? 🧁🤍🧁🤍🧁🤍🧁 192 of these decorated little cuties are headed to the post office bright and early tomorrow! (Once they’re fully dry) Keep an eye on your inbox for tracking numbers! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horsetreats #horsecookies #horsecookieart

Big Red is ready for the major March treat and apparel reveal! New muffins, cookies, merch and more! Keep an eye on our pages on Saturday 3/12 for new releases, sales and discount codes! #equestrian #equine #horse #pony #poniesofinstagram #horsesofinstagram #horsetreats #gourmethorsetreats #hunterjumper #equitation #showjumping #huntseat #sidesaddle #dressage #eventing #endurance #barrelracing #teampenning #roping #westernpleasure #trailride #horsebackriding #tackshop #smallbusiness #equinesmallbusiness #barngirl #backinthesaddle #horsecookies #heartyhorse #heartyhorsecookieco

Hearty Horse Cookie Co. has relocated to Long Island and ovens are on just in time for Valentines Day! Very limited release so keep an eye on our page so your pony pal doesn’t miss out! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horsetreats #horsecookies

Butterscotch blossoms are always a hit! Thank you @esa.equestrian and Woody for modeling and taste testing! Don’t forget to tag @heartyhorsecookieco to get featured on our page! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #cranberryacresequestrian #hellospring #butterscotchblossom

Check out @paintmedappled for this adorable Harry Potter Collaboration! Hearty Horse Harry Potter Cookie Collection paired with Butter Beer scented leather balm and a Hogwarts Express Ticket Candy Bar..... yes please!

hearty horse cookie co. is back with tons of fun, new designs 💕 from treats to hoodies, we’ve got you covered and we are so excited to see what 2021 will hold for us! Shop our newest goodies now! www.heartyhorsecookieco.com #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horsetreats #equestrian #hunterjumper #horsesofinstagram #poniesofinstagram #ponyparty #rodeo #barngirls #equine #gourmethorsetreats #homemadehorsetreats #2021

hearty horse cookie co. will be reopening on Monday, January 18th will lots of new goodies for you and your horse! We are super excited... are you? See you soon 🐴 #hearthorsecookieco #heartyhorse #horsetreats #homemadehorsetreats #horsecookies #ponytreats #hunterjumper #therapeuticriding #equestrian #horsegirlvibes

Rafiki and @nikki_barnes74 spreading some christmas cheer ❤️💚 📸: @nikki_barnes74 #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorse #christmaspony #holidays #horsegirlholiday

BLACK FRIDAY & SMALL BUSINESS SATURDAY SALE ✨ www.heartyhorsecookieco.com A few favorites on sale in our shop and free gifts automatically added based on your subtotal (before shipping) No promocodes needed! Happy shopping!

Holiday treats will be dropping throughout the week! Keep an eye out for great gift ideas for trainers, barn buddies, best friends and more!

🖤🧡Happy Halloween🧡🖤 🧡🖤🧡 HHCC 🧡🖤🧡

You can now pick up your favorite treats at @horsemans.exchange 💙 These super fun blue uni muffins are only available at Horseman’s so you better get there quick before they’re sold out! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorsecookies #heartyhorsecookie #horsemansexchange #tackshop #hunterjumper #unicornhorsetreats #unicorns #horsetreats

Last chance to scoop up our summer favorites as we make room for fall goodies! ☀️🍦🍉🌼🐝 Stars and Stripes, Sweet Summer, Hello Summer, and Bumble Muffins will only be here until the end of September!

sneak peak of our newest cookie pack ⚡️ #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorsecookie #heartyhorse #horsetreats #equestrian #sneakpeak #gourmethorsetreats #september #englishplussizedrider #hunterjumper #plussizeequestrian #horsegirls #barngirls #harrypotterhorse #harrypotterhorsetreats #hogwarts #hogwartshorse

Final day to scoop up a free box of donuts with any purchase over $75 🍩 No promo code needed! Great opportunity for a group order with your barn friends!

DONUT forget that you can scoop up a free pack of donuts with all purchases $75 and up! No promo code needed! www.heartyhorsecookieco.com 🍩🦄❤️🐴 #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorsecookie #heartyhorse #madewithlove #bakedwithlove #donuts #donutsforhorses #freehorsetreats #horsetreats #handmadehorsetreats #gourmethorsetreats #sale #tackshop #equinesmallbusiness

A super cute Golden Hour Nameplate Set heading all the way to McKenna Emily in Oregon! Get yours today! #heartyhorsecookieco #heartyhorsecookie #heartyhorse #goldenhour #nameplate #horse #barn #stall #farm #sunflower #horseshoe #horsetreats #oregon